Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Greg Abbott Tried to Destroy Muslim Group By Calling Them Terrorists. Texas Voters Balked.
Texas Republicans Greg Abbott and Ken Paxton’s effort to restrict the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) has been weakened by election results. Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa has pledged to reverse Abbott’s designation of CAIR as a foreign terrorist organisation, while Paxton has dropped a lawsuit that sought to bar the group from operating in Texas.
Abbott’s proclamation also named CAIR’s Texas chapter and the Muslim Brotherhood, and barred the groups from acquiring land in the state; CAIR is still challenging the designation in court. CAIR says the proclamation discouraged some donations and made some mosques wary of hosting it, but also brought new supporters. The group increased voter outreach at mosques, and its political wing reported a 78.6 per cent rise in early voting by Texas Muslims since 2018.
In short
- Hinojosa has pledged to reverse Abbott’s designation of CAIR.
- Paxton dropped his lawsuit to ban CAIR from Texas.
- CAIR reported a 78.6 per cent rise in early voting since 2018.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters of Abbott’s action could argue that elected officials have a duty to scrutinise organisations they believe may have links to extremist movements, and that restricting land purchases or seeking legal limits can be justified as precautionary measures to protect public safety. They may also say that designation is a matter for courts to review, and that stronger action is warranted if the state believes existing safeguards are insufficient.
The case against
Opponents could argue that branding CAIR a foreign terrorist organisation without a court finding risks wrongly stigmatising a Muslim civil-rights group and chilling lawful speech, donations and community activity. They may contend that such restrictions should rest on clear evidence and due process, and that voters’ response and the dropped lawsuit show why political leaders should not use state power to target advocacy groups on contested grounds.
Explained simply
The Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) is a US Muslim civil rights and advocacy organisation with chapters across the country, including in Texas. It campaigns on issues affecting Muslims and has also been involved in voter outreach.
Texas Governor Greg Abbott issued a proclamation labelling CAIR and its Texas chapter, along with the Muslim Brotherhood, foreign terrorist organisations. The proclamation also sought to prevent the named groups from acquiring land in Texas; CAIR disputes the designation in court.
The dispute matters because the designation can affect how organisations operate and how people view them. CAIR says it has faced hesitation from some donors and mosques, while also gaining supporters and encouraging Muslim voter participation.