World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Measles has come raging back in the US. Robert F Kennedy Jr should be impeached | Judith Levine
The article argues that US health secretary Robert F Kennedy Jr should be impeached, holding him responsible for a sharp return of measles and preventable deaths. It says his promotion of vaccine misinformation and changes to federal vaccine advice have weakened confidence and the response to outbreaks.
The US has recorded more than 7,700 measles cases since January 2025, with at least 11 deaths; outbreaks have reached 47 states. Most people who became seriously ill or died were unvaccinated, and on 17 November the Pan American Health Organization withdrew the US’s measles elimination status, held since 2000. The article also cites hospitalisations and pregnancy complications, and criticises Kennedy’s dismissal of all 17 members of the CDC’s immunisation advisory committee.
In short
- Measles cases have surged across 47 US states.
- At least 11 people have died since January 2025.
- The US has lost its measles elimination status.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters of impeachment could argue that a health secretary who promotes vaccine misinformation, alters federal guidance and dismisses the full immunisation advisory committee has undermined public trust and the government’s ability to contain a preventable disease. With thousands of cases, deaths and the loss of US measles elimination status, they could say Congress has a duty to hold him accountable for serious failures in public health leadership.
The case against
Opponents could argue that impeachment is an exceptional remedy and that the reported outbreak, though grave, does not by itself establish impeachable misconduct or prove that Kennedy’s actions caused it. They could favour scrutiny through hearings and ordinary oversight, while allowing room to debate vaccine policy and arguing that accountability should rest on evidence of specific abuses or failures.
Explained simply
Measles is a highly contagious virus that can cause serious illness, especially in young children and people with weakened immune systems. Vaccination with the MMR jab greatly reduces the risk of infection and helps prevent outbreaks by limiting the virus’s spread.
In the US, vaccination advice is shaped by federal health agencies, including the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). Its immunisation advisory committee reviews evidence and recommends which vaccines people should receive. Health secretary Robert F Kennedy Jr leads the federal health department, which oversees these agencies.
The US had been recognised as having eliminated measles transmission in 2000, meaning the virus was no longer spreading continuously within the country. That status depends on keeping outbreaks under control; imported cases can still occur. Changes to vaccine advice or public confidence can affect vaccination rates and the ability to contain the virus.