Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Grieving families must get millions stripped from evil killers and violent criminals after ‘cruel loophole’ closed
Emma Webber has called on the Government to direct money saved by ending benefit payments to serious offenders in secure hospitals towards support for victims’ families. She welcomed the change as a long-overdue step, but said bereaved families need practical support and advocacy.
The policy, announced in October and expected to take effect in early 2027, will end eligibility for Universal Credit, Pension Credit, State Pension and Employment and Support Allowance during detention. It is expected to affect about 2,500 people already in hospital and around 200 more each year, saving tens of millions of pounds annually. Webber estimates about £25 million could be recovered, while the Ministry of Justice currently provides as little as £5 million for homicide victim support.
In short
- Emma Webber wants savings redirected to victims’ families.
- Benefit payments to serious offenders in secure hospitals will end.
- The change could save tens of millions of pounds each year.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Ending benefits for people detained in secure hospitals after serious offending may be seen as a fair use of public funds: those unable to access ordinary work or services while detained should not automatically receive payments intended to support people living in the community. Redirecting some of the savings to bereaved families could also address a significant gap in practical help and advocacy after homicide.
The case against
Benefit eligibility during detention can be defended as a matter of individual entitlement and rehabilitation, since detention does not itself remove a person’s basic needs or the costs of maintaining family and community ties. Savings are not guaranteed to translate into better victim support, so that support may be better funded through a clear, sustained commitment rather than relying on money taken from a group of vulnerable people.