Technology news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Teachers are ‘quietly’ given official permission to use AI chatbots when marking exam coursework in ‘scandalous’ move, critics say
New guidance from the Joint Council for Qualifications (JCQ) allows teachers to use AI tools when marking exam coursework, provided a person remains responsible for the final mark. The policy has prompted criticism from an educationalist who says it risks unreliable grades and undermines the contrast between students being restricted from using AI and teachers using it to assess their work.
Dr Will Van Reyk of St Paul’s School argues that mainstream chatbots such as ChatGPT and Microsoft Copilot lack evidence of being suitable for marking, and says teachers have not been trained to use them. He says the guidance is buried in a 55-page document and sets no standards for teachers. JCQ says its rules follow the regulator’s position and make clear AI must not be the primary or sole means of marking; the article provides no further response beyond that statement.
In short
- JCQ guidance permits teachers to use AI in marking coursework.
- A school leader says mainstream chatbots could produce unreliable marks.
- JCQ says AI cannot be the primary or sole marker.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
AI tools could help teachers handle the time-consuming work of marking coursework, while a teacher remains accountable for checking the result and assigning the final mark. If used cautiously under the regulator’s rules, they may offer practical support without replacing professional judgement.
The case against
Coursework marks can affect students’ qualifications, so tools without established evidence of marking reliability may introduce errors or unfairness. If teachers lack training and clear standards, human oversight may not be enough to catch those errors; allowing teachers to use AI while restricting students’ use may also raise concerns about consistency and trust.
Explained simply
The Joint Council for Qualifications (JCQ) is an organisation that represents exam boards in the UK and issues guidance on qualifications and assessment. Coursework is work completed by students during a course, rather than in a timed exam, and may count towards their final qualification.
AI chatbots such as ChatGPT and Microsoft Copilot generate responses to questions and can be used for tasks including analysing written work. In coursework assessment, teachers decide students’ marks and are responsible for them; the debate is over what role, if any, these tools should play in helping with that judgement.
The issue matters because coursework marks can affect students’ qualifications and future opportunities. It also raises questions about how schools should use AI fairly, and what training or safeguards teachers need when using it.