Technology news and discussion on TalkFuse.
The Binding of Isaac Dev Removes Undisclosed AI-Generated Music From Repentance+ Following Creator Response, Review-Bombing
Nicalis removed undisclosed AI-generated music from The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ after players criticised its inclusion and Steam reviews turned sharply negative. Creator Edmund McMillen said he had not known the music was in the update and was looking into how it got there.
Players traced the music to a Grand Theft Auto-themed daily run and found metadata linking some tracks to the AI music service Suno. The update launched on 19 November 2026, and only 8% of its recent Steam reviews were positive. Nicalis released a PC patch removing the files and submitted it to console makers, but gave no explanation for their inclusion.
In short
- Nicalis removed AI-generated music from Repentance+.
- Tracks were linked to Suno in their metadata.
- Only 8% of recent Steam reviews were positive.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Players and developers can reasonably object to AI-generated music being added without disclosure: people may want to know how a game’s music was made, and undisclosed use can undermine trust in the creators’ artistic choices. Removing the tracks and explaining how they entered the update could help restore confidence and respect players’ expectations.
The case against
A developer or publisher might argue that AI tools can be legitimate parts of music production and that their use alone does not determine whether a track is suitable. If the music met the game’s creative and technical standards, removing it in response to a review backlash could seem premature; the lack of an explanation also leaves open whether the issue was the music itself, its undisclosed use, or how it was introduced.
AI Entertainment Gaming Music Software Technology