World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Scotland open to reviewing consent age if evidence supports change
Scotland’s Justice Secretary Neil Gray says the Government would consider evidence-based proposals to change the age of consent following the Russell Brand case, while stressing that there are no current plans to alter the law. The debate has been renewed by Mia Latter, who says Brand raped her when she was 16 and has waived her right to anonymity to campaign for a staggered age of consent.
The age of consent in Scotland is 16, and the Scottish Government decides whether to change it because the issue is devolved to Holyrood. Gray said the law already criminalises sexual activity between an adult aged 18 or over and a 16- or 17-year-old when the adult is in a position of trust; he said any further change would need evidence that it improves protection without making the law confusing. Scottish Liberal Democrats support examining a staggered age, while the Scottish Conservatives say any legal changes need careful consideration and should not be the only response.
In short
- Scotland has no current plan to change its age of consent.
- Neil Gray says evidence-based proposals will be considered.
- The law already restricts activity where an adult is in a position of trust.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A staggered age of consent could give stronger protection to 16- and 17-year-olds from exploitation by substantially older adults, while recognising that the same rules may not be needed for relationships between people close in age. Supporters argue that reviewing the law on evidence could close gaps in protection without treating all young people’s relationships alike.
The case against
Changing the age rules could make the law harder to understand or risk criminalising consensual relationships between young people, so any proposal needs careful scrutiny of its effects. The existing law already criminalises sexual activity with 16- and 17-year-olds by adults in positions of trust, and stronger protection may also require responses beyond changing the age of consent.
Explained simply
The age of consent is the legal age at which a person can agree to sexual activity. In Scotland it is 16, and responsibility for changing the law rests with the Scottish Parliament and Government at Holyrood.
The debate has been renewed by Mia Latter, who says Russell Brand raped her when she was 16 and is campaigning for different consent ages in some circumstances. She has given up her right to anonymity, which otherwise protects people who report sexual offences.
Scottish law already makes sexual activity with a 16- or 17-year-old a crime when an adult aged 18 or over is in a position of trust. Any wider change could affect how the law protects young people and is applied, so proposals raise questions about evidence and clarity.
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by Daily Mail as “After the Russell Brand scandal, age of consent will be reviewed in Scotland if ‘evidence based proposals’ are brought forward”.