World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Andy Burnham’s biggest myth busted
New Office for National Statistics figures suggest UK productivity growth has been stronger than previously estimated, challenging claims that leaving the EU has directly harmed the economy. The data is relevant to debate over closer UK-EU ties, though it does not by itself establish what Brexit’s economic impact has been.
Using a revised measure of output per hour, the ONS found UK productivity grew faster than Germany, France and Italy from 1997, and that among G7 countries only the US recorded stronger growth. The ONS cautioned that international comparisons are affected by differences in measurement. Economist Simon French said the figures call into question estimates that Brexit reduced UK productivity by 3 to 4 per cent; Andy Burnham has argued a closer EU partnership could add 0.4 per cent to GDP.
In short
- Revised ONS figures show stronger UK productivity growth than previously thought.
- The UK outpaced Germany, France and Italy from 1997.
- The data adds context to claims about Brexit’s economic impact.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The revised figures suggest UK productivity has performed better than some earlier estimates implied, so claims that Brexit directly caused a large productivity loss may be overstated. They also caution against using past EU membership alone to infer that closer ties would produce a substantial economic gain.
The case against
Productivity growth since 1997 does not show what UK productivity would have been without Brexit, and the ONS notes that international comparisons depend on measurement choices. The figures therefore do not rule out Brexit having reduced productivity relative to a plausible alternative, or closer EU partnership bringing future economic benefits.
Explained simply
Productivity measures how much an economy produces for each hour worked. Economists use it to compare changes in output over time, but the figures can vary depending on how output and working hours are measured.
The Office for National Statistics produces UK economic data, while international comparisons also involve statistical agencies in other countries. Andy Burnham, the mayor of Greater Manchester, has argued for a closer partnership between the UK and EU; economists have also estimated how Brexit may have affected productivity.
These figures matter because productivity growth is linked to how quickly an economy can expand and living standards can rise. They inform debate about the UK’s relationship with the EU, but comparisons alone cannot establish what effect Brexit has had.
Americas Business Economy Europe UK World