IGN’s review finds Apple TV’s Brothers a weak and confused vehicle for Matthew McConaughey and Woody Harrelson, despite their proven chemistry and shared history from True Detective. The series fictionalises the actors as themselves, but its central premise—that Woody may be Matthew’s biological half-brother—is largely kept in the background, while the main plot follows Matthew’s unconvincing campaign to become Governor of Texas.

The review says the show struggles to sustain its eight episodes and repeatedly changes its comedic focus, initially presenting Matthew as the straight man before portraying both actors as equally clueless celebrities. Although the pair’s natural rapport offers some early charm, this fades as the series relies on predictable sitcom plots, including failed musical performances, disguises and forgotten Valentine’s Day gifts; the review concludes that their chemistry is rarely used imaginatively.