News, events and chat from Sheffield and South Yorkshire.
Challinor’s record fits the bill for Wednesday
Sheffield Wednesday’s new owners have appointed Dave Challinor to turn recent draws and defeats into wins. His record of seven promotions and experience in League One at Stockport County suit the task, but he must build a team from a squad of talented individuals.
The challenge comes with high expectations: Wednesday are expected to win regularly in League One, where the leading group is taking shape and Leicester and MK Dons may also contend. Challinor’s previous roles at Stockport, Hartlepool and Fylde differ from this high-pressure job; his working relationship with Simon Wilson, who helped shape the appointment, could be important.
In short
- Challinor brings seven promotions to Sheffield Wednesday.
- He must turn individual talent into a winning team.
- League One expectations will make the job demanding.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Challinor’s seven promotions and experience winning in League One make him a credible choice to turn Wednesday’s results around. His success at Stockport suggests he can build a team from talented individuals, while his relationship with Simon Wilson may help provide continuity and support as he takes on a demanding job.
The case against
Promotion success elsewhere does not guarantee results at a club with Wednesday’s expectations, where regular wins are demanded and rivals such as Leicester and MK Dons may also contend. Challinor’s previous roles differ from this high-pressure environment, and turning a squad of talented individuals into a coherent team may prove harder than his record alone suggests.