Science news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Ed Miliband explains stance on Rosebank oil field after previous criticism
Ed Miliband says he would stay in the Cabinet if the government approves the Rosebank oil field, despite having previously condemned it as a waste of public money and harmful to the climate. He says collective responsibility would require him to accept the government’s decision, as debate over the project tests Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s administration.
Energy Secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh will decide Rosebank’s fate; the development lies north-west of Shetland and has yet to receive approval. At least 75 Labour MPs have signed a letter opposing it, while one parliamentary private secretary is reportedly considering resigning if it proceeds. The government has approved the Jackdaw gas field, where production has begun; its operator says the gas will support jobs and energy security.
In short
- Miliband says he will stay in Cabinet if Rosebank is approved.
- At least 75 Labour MPs oppose the oil field.
- Jackdaw has been approved and is now producing gas.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters could argue that approving Rosebank may help sustain domestic energy production, jobs and energy security while the transition to lower-carbon sources is under way. They may also see Miliband’s willingness to accept a Cabinet decision as a legitimate expression of collective responsibility, even where ministers have previously disagreed.
The case against
Opponents could argue that developing Rosebank would commit public and private resources to new oil production, undermine climate goals and risk delaying the shift to cleaner energy. They may also contend that a project with such environmental and political stakes deserves clear accountability, rather than Cabinet solidarity muting a minister’s previously stated objections.
Explained simply
Rosebank is a proposed oil field in the North Sea, north-west of Shetland. It has not yet been approved, and the decision rests with Energy Secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh.
The project has divided Labour: at least 75 of the party’s MPs have opposed it, and a parliamentary aide is reportedly considering resigning if it goes ahead. Supporters of new oil and gas development argue it can help provide energy and sustain jobs, while critics point to its climate effects and the use of public money.
The government has approved the Jackdaw gas field, where production has started, giving the Rosebank debate a wider context. Ed Miliband, a senior minister who previously criticised Rosebank, says he would remain in the Cabinet if the government approved it; his position touches on how ministers are expected to support collective decisions.