Business news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Employers are being asked to give interview feedback – here’s what applicants want
Young UK jobseekers say employers often leave them without a response after applications or interviews, damaging confidence and making it harder to learn from setbacks. A review led by former minister Alan Milburn has proposed that large employers give unsuccessful applicants under 25 meaningful feedback, as part of efforts to reduce the number of young people not in education, employment or training.
The report aims to reduce the share of young people classed as NEET from 13% to about 5% by 2036, and its proposals mainly concern England. One survey by recruitment firm Robert Walters found 86% of UK job hunters said their applications had been ignored. Employers cite high application volumes and AI-assisted mass applications, while a career coach says automated replies could at least confirm rejection and interviewees should receive pointers they can use.
In short
- Young applicants say job ghosting undermines confidence.
- Milburn proposes feedback for unsuccessful applicants under 25.
- 86% of UK job hunters surveyed said applications were ignored.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Requiring large employers to give unsuccessful applicants under 25 useful feedback could help young people learn from setbacks, maintain confidence and make better-informed applications. Even where detailed comments are impractical, a clear response and brief pointers could make recruitment feel more transparent and support efforts to reduce youth unemployment and inactivity.
The case against
Employers may receive very large numbers of applications, including mass submissions aided by AI, making tailored feedback for every unsuccessful young applicant costly and difficult to deliver consistently. A requirement could divert time from recruitment or produce generic comments that offer little practical help, while employers may argue that clear, automated updates are a more workable minimum.
Explained simply
Young people who are not in education, employment or training are often described as NEET. In England, a review led by former minister Alan Milburn has set out proposals aimed at reducing the number in this group, including better support to help young people find work.
Many applicants say they hear nothing after applying for a job or attending an interview. Employers point to the large number of applications they receive, while career advisers say a clear rejection and useful feedback can help applicants understand what to improve.