Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
“Essentially Worthless” – Disgruntled Fans Are Review Bombing Pikmin 4 On Switch 2
Pikmin 4’s Switch 2 edition has received a user score of 2.3 on Metacritic, despite an 83 metascore, as some players object to paying for what they consider a minor upgrade. The backlash highlights differing views on whether its visual improvements and new content justify the price.
The edition adds 4K visuals, Dandori Academy and voice commands, and costs £7.99, $9.99 or €9.99. The article found that leaving a cave took around 14 to 15 seconds in its test, compared with about six seconds on the original Switch; some other reports cited waits of more than 30 seconds. It also notes complaints about the lack of mouse controls and 60fps performance.
In short
- Pikmin 4’s Switch 2 user score is 2.3 on Metacritic.
- Players are criticising the paid upgrade’s value.
- One test found cave exits took 14 to 15 seconds.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters of the Switch 2 edition can argue that its 4K visuals, added Dandori Academy content and voice commands make it more than a simple re-release, while the upgrade price is lower than buying a new game. For players who value those additions or are new to Pikmin 4, the package may offer worthwhile improvements.
The case against
Critics can argue that the changes are too limited to justify charging again for a game many players already own, particularly when performance remains capped at 30fps and mouse controls are absent. Reports of longer cave-loading times also raise concern that the edition does not consistently improve the experience, making the upgrade poor value for some existing owners.
Explained simply
Pikmin 4 is a strategy adventure game made by Nintendo, first released for the original Switch. Players direct small plant-like creatures called Pikmin to solve puzzles, gather objects and explore areas, including underground caves.
Nintendo has released an edition for Switch 2, its newer console. It adds sharper visuals, a Dandori Academy mode and voice commands; owners of the original game can pay an upgrade fee to access it. Dandori is the game’s term for organising tasks and Pikmin efficiently.
Players disagree over whether these additions justify the cost. Their reactions reflect broader questions about what makes a paid upgrade worthwhile, including how much new content or improved performance it should provide.