Culture news and discussion on TalkFuse.
‘Mick Jagger should fold up his penis and go home’: the caustic genius of music critic Robert Christgau
Robert Christgau, the influential American music critic known for both scathing reviews and enthusiastic praise, is the subject of a new documentary, *The Last Critic*. The film follows his continuing work in his mid-80s and explores how his writing shaped listeners’ ideas about music and the divide between popular and critically acclaimed artists.
Christgau created his monthly Consumer Guide at the *Village Voice*, where he was a leading music critic and editor from the late 1960s until 2006. He grades albums from A+ to E, and now publishes the feature on Substack, which reportedly provides him with a decent income. Director Matty Wishnow also centres the film on Christgau’s partnership with his wife, Carola Dibbell, whom he describes as a key intellectual and artistic companion.
In short
- Robert Christgau is profiled in a new documentary.
- His Consumer Guide grades albums from A+ to E.
- The film explores his lasting influence and partnership with Carola Dibbell.
Explained simply
Robert Christgau is an American music critic whose reviews have often been blunt and sharply phrased. From the late 1960s, he wrote for and edited the Village Voice, a New York newspaper, at a time when rock music and its audiences were expanding.
His Consumer Guide rates albums from A+ to E, mixing criticism with recommendations for readers. Christgau’s work has helped shape discussion about popular music and the difference between commercial success and critical acclaim. His wife, Carola Dibbell, is also a writer and musician and has been an important creative partner.