Fan backlash as gay World Cup star joins Saudi club
Spain forward Esther Gonzalez has faced criticism after joining Saudi Women’s Premier League club Al Qadsiah, shortly after leaving Gotham FC for what were described as personal reasons. The move matters because Gonzalez is openly gay and Saudi Arabia criminalises same-sex relationships, prompting concerns about her safety and accusations that the circumstances of her Gotham departure were unclear.
The 33-year-old, a 2023 World Cup winner, ended her Gotham contract by mutual agreement in July despite it running until 2027, meaning the club received no transfer fee. Reports say she removed social-media photographs featuring her wife and child after the Saudi move; Al Qadsiah finished fourth in the 2025-26 league season.
In short
- Gay Spain star Esther Gonzalez joins Saudi club Al Qadsiah.
- Fans question her departure from Gotham FC.
- Saudi law criminalises same-sex relationships.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Gonzalez is an adult professional entitled to choose where she works, and a move to Saudi Arabia may offer sporting, financial or personal opportunities that outsiders cannot fully assess. Playing there could also help raise the profile of women’s football and create connections across borders, while her private family choices should not be treated as proof of coercion.
The case against
Because Saudi Arabia criminalises same-sex relationships, critics can reasonably worry that an openly gay player may face legal, personal or professional risks, and that removing family photographs could reflect pressure to conceal her identity. The circumstances of her early Gotham departure and the lack of a transfer fee may also prompt questions about whether the move was fully transparent, even though those details alone do not establish wrongdoing.
Explained simply
Esther González is a Spanish striker who helped Spain win the 2023 Women’s World Cup. She previously played for Gotham FC, a club in the top US women’s league, and is married to a woman.
Al Qadsiah is a Saudi football club competing in the country’s women’s league. Saudi Arabia criminalises same-sex relationships, so González’s move has drawn attention to the circumstances facing an openly gay player there and to questions about her departure from Gotham.
Celebrity Entertainment Europe Football Middle East Sport World