Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Festivus came early to Babylon
Babylon residents challenged a proposed town budget at a 5 November meeting after it included a nearly 6% tax increase, exceeding New York’s 2% cap, and a 29% raise for the supervisor. The town revised the plan to remove the raises, and Supervisor Rich Schaffer said he would reduce his salary to $120,000, showing that public pressure can prompt change.
The article argues that residents’ influence is more limited at the earlier budget negotiations between elected officials and public-sector unions, where spending decisions are made. Schaffer described the proposed raise as a ceiling and cited an average annual increase of 1%; the author contrasts it with what would happen if an investment manager sought a 29% pay rise.
In short
- Babylon residents pressed the town to revise its proposed budget.
- The plan’s nearly 6% tax rise exceeded New York’s 2% cap.
- The author says key spending decisions are made during union bargaining.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Residents have a strong case for scrutinising a budget that proposed a tax increase above New York’s cap and a substantial raise for the supervisor. Public objections prompted changes, showing that open meetings and civic pressure can make elected officials more accountable. Residents may also reasonably want more influence earlier, when officials and public-sector unions negotiate spending commitments that shape the budget.
The case against
Town officials can argue that a proposed budget is an opening plan, not a final decision, and that revising it after public feedback is evidence the process can work. A proposed salary ceiling need not mean the supervisor would receive that full increase, and pay decisions can involve considerations beyond comparisons with private-sector investment managers. Negotiations with public-sector unions also require room for elected officials to weigh pay, services and other town obligations before presenting a budget.
Explained simply
Babylon is a town on Long Island in New York State. Its budget sets how much the town plans to spend and how much it expects to collect in taxes; state law limits most local tax levy increases to 2%, subject to exceptions.
The town supervisor is an elected official who leads its government, while public-sector unions represent many town employees in pay negotiations. Those talks help shape the budget before it is presented at a public meeting, where residents can question the plan.