Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Fourth Circuit Panel Splits Three Ways on Kalshi Preemption
A divided Fourth Circuit panel upheld a lower court ruling in a dispute over whether federal law prevents Maryland from regulating Kalshi’s sports event contracts. The split leaves the legal relationship between federal oversight of derivatives and state gambling laws unsettled, with implications for prediction markets and state regulators.
The three judges produced four opinions: a brief ruling affirming the district court, two concurrences and a dissent. Judges Gregory and Thacker agreed that federal law does not pre-empt Maryland’s rules, but disagreed on whether the contracts qualify as “swaps”; Judge Benjamin found that they do qualify and are pre-empted. The article says two judges considered the contracts swaps and two opposed pre-emption, while two also viewed the classification question as relevant to the pre-emption issue.
In short
- The Fourth Circuit affirmed the district court in Kalshi’s Maryland dispute.
- The three judges split on swaps and federal pre-emption.
- The ruling leaves the reach of state gambling laws unresolved.