Nathan Fielder’s film explores Elizabeth Holmes’s claims of innocence
Comedian and filmmaker Nathan Fielder and director Lance Oppenheim document Elizabeth Holmes in *You Can See Everything*, a film that began as Holmes’s effort to shape public perception before she entered prison in 2023. Their conversations put two ambiguous public personas side by side and leave viewers weighing whether Holmes believes her repeated claims that she did nothing wrong.
The article recalls that Holmes was convicted of fraud over Theranos, whose blood-testing devices did not work as claimed, and sentenced to 11 years. Investors lost hundreds of millions of dollars, whistleblowers raised concerns, and patients received incorrect results. Holmes maintains that she committed no crime; the review explores how the film handles her account and her dispute over a quote in a New York Times profile.
- Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim film Elizabeth Holmes before her prison sentence.
- Holmes continues to say she did nothing wrong.
- The film examines the uncertain line between persona and reality.
Both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Holmes’s conviction and the harm linked to Theranos are established, but a film can still examine whether she sincerely believes her claims and how she understands her actions. Giving her account room to be heard may help viewers assess the gap between her self-image and the evidence, rather than reducing her to a verdict.
The case against
A film centred on Holmes’s claims of innocence risks giving a convicted fraudster’s self-presentation undue weight, especially when patients received incorrect results and investors lost substantial sums. Viewers may reasonably question whether the film’s ambiguity and focus on her persona obscure the documented harm or turn accountability into a debate about whether she believes herself.
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by TechCrunch as “In ‘You Can See Everything,’ Elizabeth Holmes meets her equal in comedian Nathan Fielder”.