Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
JOHN MacLEOD: NEETs crisis deserves more than McAllan’s whataboutery and pointless, performative railings against Brexit
Alan Milburn’s report on young people outside education, employment or training has prompted criticism from politicians, including Scottish minister Màiri McAllan, who objects to the term “NEET”. The article argues that the debate should focus on the scale of the problem and how to improve opportunities, rather than on terminology or political point-scoring.
It says almost one million people aged 16 to 24 in Britain are NEET, describing this as both a loss for those young people and a missed national opportunity. The writer cites Milburn’s view that the issue is a crisis of opportunity, not aspiration, and argues that political leaders should engage with the report’s evidence and proposals. The supplied article text ends before setting out those proposals.
In short
- Almost one million 16 to 24-year-olds are NEET.
- Milburn describes the issue as a crisis of opportunity.
- The article urges politicians to focus on solutions.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Using “NEET” can provide a concise, widely understood way to identify a serious problem and focus attention on the number of young people missing out on education, work or training. Supporters of the article’s approach would argue that leaders should engage with the evidence and practical proposals, because clearer opportunities could benefit young people and the wider country.
The case against
Critics may object that “NEET” reduces people with varied circumstances to a label that can carry stigma, and that respectful language matters when designing policy around them. They could also argue that scrutiny of the report’s terms and political context is legitimate, and that addressing the scale of the problem requires examining its causes—including economic and policy choices—rather than treating debate about language or Brexit as mere point-scoring.
Explained simply
“NEET” is a shorthand for young people who are not in education, employment or training. Alan Milburn, a former Labour health secretary, has written a report about young people in this position; Scottish minister Màiri McAllan has criticised the term.
The issue concerns people aged 16 to 24 across Britain, with the article citing a figure of almost one million. It raises questions about access to education, work and training, and the effects on both young people and the wider country.
The report has prompted political debate about how the problem should be described and addressed. Understanding its scale and the barriers young people face is central to considering what could improve their opportunities.
Elections Government Politics World