World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Milburn’s absurdly ambitious report offers blueprint for fixing everything and everyone
Alan Milburn’s review of young people who are not in education, employment or training (NEET) proposes far-reaching changes to jobs, training, schools, the NHS and welfare. It argues that the state should help young people into work and give them greater security and purpose, while rejecting the idea that they are simply lazy or unambitious.
The report says about 1 million people aged 16 to 24 are NEET and calls for twice as many youth apprenticeships, specialist careers advisers and a stronger expectation that young people work or train. Its welfare proposals would replace a £2,000 monthly income for some young disabled claimants with £339 a month, with benefits potentially cut by £3.6bn over 10 years. The article notes concerns that disability benefit cuts could deepen poverty and harm mental health, and that the proposals may face opposition within Labour.
In short
- Milburn proposes sweeping reforms to tackle youth unemployment.
- The report calls for more apprenticeships and compulsory engagement.
- Disability benefit reductions could face political and poverty concerns.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters could argue that a million young people outside work or training represents a serious failure of opportunity, and that coordinated action across schools, employers, health services and welfare is needed to address its causes. More apprenticeships and tailored careers advice could open routes into work, while a stronger expectation to work or train may help provide structure, skills and purpose. They may see reforming benefits as part of directing limited public funds towards employment support and long-term independence.
The case against
Critics could argue that reducing support for disabled young people risks pushing people with substantial needs into poverty, worsening their mental health and making it harder to take part in work or training. A broad expectation to work or train may not account for illness, disability or barriers such as poor access to suitable jobs and services. They may also question whether sweeping reforms across many institutions can deliver the promised opportunities, especially if benefit cuts weaken the security young people need.
Explained simply
NEET is a term for young people who are not in education, employment or training. It covers people in different situations, including those looking for work and those unable to work because of health or caring responsibilities. The number of young people in this group has become a concern for policymakers because time out of education or work can affect future opportunities.
Alan Milburn is a former Labour health secretary who was asked to review the issue. His work looks across schools, training, employment, health services and welfare, reflecting the range of reasons young people may be out of work or study. Apprenticeships and careers advice are among the routes governments use to help young people move into jobs.
Welfare support is also part of the debate because some young people with disabilities rely on benefits when they cannot work. Changes to eligibility or payment levels can affect their income and wellbeing, while governments also consider the cost of support and ways to encourage employment.