Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Never Trumpers Turn On Each Other As Their Reason For Existing Begins To Evaporate
Several prominent conservative critics of Donald Trump clashed over what the “Never Trump” label means after Sarah Longwell described herself as a “lib” while celebrating Democrats’ midterm gains. The dispute highlights tensions among anti-Trump conservatives as they reassess their political identity and the movement’s purpose amid a Democratic “blue wave” and what the article describes as the approaching end of the Trump era.
Babylon Bee writer Frank Fleming questioned whether staunch Trump supporters and staunch opponents had both abandoned principle, while Bulwark editor Jonah Goldberg called the two outlooks equivalent. Longwell rejected that comparison and criticised anti-Trump conservatives who, she said, would not back Kamala Harris in 2024; Goldberg later accused her of acting as a political operative and argued that the Bulwark’s rationale was fading. The supplied article text ends mid-sentence during Goldberg’s response.
In short
- Sarah Longwell’s “lib” comment reignited a dispute among Trump critics.
- Jonah Goldberg accused her of political team-playing.
- The clash reflects uncertainty over Never Trump conservatism’s future.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Anti-Trump conservatives can argue that opposing Trump reflects enduring commitments to constitutional limits, democratic norms and accountable government, rather than a temporary dislike of one politician. From this perspective, backing Democrats when they are seen as defending those principles can be consistent, and critics who refuse such cooperation risk treating party identity as more important than the values they claim to uphold.
The case against
Other conservatives can argue that opposition to Trump need not require becoming liberal or supporting Democratic candidates whose policies they reject. Keeping a distinct conservative identity may preserve space to criticise both parties and make the movement’s principles clearer; if the immediate Trump-era threat recedes, continuing to define a political project mainly through opposition could also leave it without a durable purpose.