Cooper says NHS staff who snoop on medical records should be dismissed
Health Secretary Yvette Cooper says NHS staff who improperly access patients’ medical records should be suspended during investigations and sacked if breaches are confirmed. Her comments follow an inquiry into suspected snooping on the records of William Chapman, who died after entering a tiger enclosure at a Yorkshire zoo.
Yorkshire Ambulance Service says two employees may have accessed or tried to access information about Chapman without a legitimate reason; routine audits uncovered the concern, which was also reported to the Information Commissioner’s Office. Chapman, 24, was pronounced dead at Yorkshire Wildlife Park on 10 October. Cooper cited 15 staff dismissed by a Nottingham hospital trust for accessing records of victims of the 2023 Nottingham attacks.
- Cooper says NHS staff who breach patient privacy should be sacked.
- Two ambulance service employees are under investigation.
- The suspected access was found through routine audits.
Both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Unauthorised access to medical records is a serious breach of patient privacy and trust, even when no information is shared. Suspending staff during an investigation and dismissing those whose misconduct is confirmed could deter snooping and reassure patients that sensitive records are protected. Comparable cases suggest employers can enforce this standard.
The case against
A firm rule of suspension and dismissal may risk treating every breach alike, without enough regard to intent, circumstances or proportionality. Staff should face fair, consistent investigations and a chance to respond; lesser or inadvertent violations may warrant a different sanction from deliberate snooping. Strong safeguards and accountability matter, but overly automatic penalties could undermine confidence in fair workplace processes.
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by Daily Mail as “NHS staff who inappropriately accessed medical records of man mauled to death by tiger at zoo should be sacked, Yvette Cooper says”.