World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
One of the world’s most contested seas is proving too much for Asia’s leaders to resolve
The dispute over a South China Sea code of conduct remains unresolved, and analysts say Singapore’s upcoming role as ASEAN chair is unlikely to break the deadlock. They argue China has little incentive to accept meaningful limits while strengthening its position in the contested waters, making a deal unlikely soon, if at all.
The negotiations have been stalled for almost 25 years, with some ASEAN members seen as reluctant to support an agreement that would constrain China. Tensions include reported Chinese coast guard actions near disputed areas, including alleged ramming of Filipino fishing boats near the Spratlys in September, as well as past use of lasers and water cannons against Philippine ships. Analysts warn that a weak code could undermine the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, which has provided the global framework for oceans since 1994.
In short
- A South China Sea code of conduct remains unlikely.
- Analysts say China has little incentive to accept meaningful restraints.
- A weak agreement could weaken the authority of UNCLOS.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A meaningful code of conduct could reduce the risk of incidents at sea, clarify expectations and give regional states a forum to manage disputes. Supporters may argue that even a negotiated agreement is better than relying on ad hoc restraint, provided it is consistent with the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea and does not legitimise coercive changes to the status quo.
The case against
Critics may argue that a code negotiated without credible enforcement or limits on conduct would offer little protection to smaller states and could give the appearance of progress while leaving the balance of power unchanged. If its terms weakened or sidestepped the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, accepting such a deal could entrench disputed claims and undermine the rules that govern maritime disputes.
Explained simply
The South China Sea is a busy route for trade and fishing, and several governments claim parts of it. China claims much of the sea, while the Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia, Brunei and Taiwan also have claims. Some of the disputed areas include small islands and reefs, such as the Spratly Islands.
The Association of Southeast Asian Nations, or ASEAN, is a group of countries in the region. For almost 25 years, ASEAN and China have been discussing a code of conduct to set rules for behaviour in the disputed waters. The UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, in force since 1994, provides wider rules for maritime claims and ocean use.
The dispute matters because confrontations at sea can affect fishing, trade and relations between governments. Countries differ over how a code should work and whether it would place meaningful limits on their actions. Any agreement would sit alongside the existing international rules for the oceans.
Asia Business Geopolitics Politics World