World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Read panicked ‘my momma’ texts sent by teen accused of gang-raping cheerleader Madi Brooks, 19, as he prepares to stand trial over night that ended with her being dumped on road to die
Desmond Carter, one of three men accused of raping LSU cheerleader Madi Brooks, is due to stand trial in Louisiana on 7 December. Texts he sent after Brooks died appear to show him saying his mother told him not to speak to police; prosecutors want them admitted, while his lawyers argue they could violate his right against self-incrimination.
Brooks, 19, died in January 2023 after being struck by an Uber shortly after she was left beside a road. The accused men say their sexual encounters with her were consensual; Carter and the other two have pleaded not guilty to the charges against them. Brooks had a blood alcohol level of .319, and a coroner found injuries consistent with rape. A judge has yet to rule on whether Carter’s texts can be used at trial.
In short
- Carter’s trial is scheduled for 7 December.
- Prosecutors want his post-incident texts admitted as evidence.
- The three accused men deny the rape allegations.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The prosecution can argue the messages are relevant evidence of Carter’s state of mind after Brooks died and may help the jury assess the events and his account. If properly authenticated and considered in context, admitting them could support a fair examination of the evidence rather than shielding potentially informative statements from scrutiny.
The case against
The defence can argue that admitting the messages risks penalising Carter for remaining silent or relying on advice not to speak to police, undermining his right against self-incrimination. Texts sent in distress may also be ambiguous or open to misleading interpretation, so excluding them could help ensure the jury decides the case on reliable evidence rather than inference.
Explained simply
Madi Brooks was a 19-year-old Louisiana State University cheerleader who died in January 2023 after being struck by a car on a road. Three men, including Desmond Carter, are accused of raping her before she was left there; all have pleaded not guilty.
The case centres on what happened before Brooks was left by the road and whether the sexual encounters were consensual, as the accused men say. A coroner reported injuries consistent with rape, and Brooks’s blood alcohol level was recorded as .319.
The trial will consider the evidence against Carter, including text messages sent after Brooks’s death. Prosecutors want the messages admitted, while his lawyers argue they could breach his right not to incriminate himself; a judge will decide whether they can be used.