World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Susan Smith denied parole again 32 years after drowning her two sons
Susan Smith has been denied parole for a second time, 32 years after she drowned her two young sons in South Carolina. The unanimous decision means she will remain in prison, while the case continues to draw attention to accountability and the possibility of release for people convicted of serious crimes.
At Thursday’s hearing, Smith, 55, said she was sorry and had changed, but disputed that an affair had motivated the killings. The boys’ father, David Smith, urged the board to reject her release, saying the passage of time did not undo what she had deliberately done. Smith was convicted in 1994 of killing Michael, aged three, and Alex, aged one; she may apply for parole again in two years.
In short
- Susan Smith’s parole request was unanimously rejected.
- She was convicted of killing her two sons in 1994.
- She can apply again in two years.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A person who has served decades in prison and expresses remorse may deserve a genuine chance to show that rehabilitation has made release safe and appropriate. Parole allows the board to assess present risk and change, rather than treating punishment as necessarily permanent, while a further application in two years preserves ongoing scrutiny.
The case against
The deliberate killing of two very young children caused irreparable harm, and their father argues that the passage of time cannot erase the seriousness of the crime. The board may reasonably conclude that the gravity of the offence and the need for accountability outweigh Smith’s claims of remorse and change, and that continued imprisonment is justified.
Explained simply
In 1994, Susan Smith was convicted in South Carolina of killing her two young sons, Michael and Alex, by drowning them in a car. The case drew national attention after she initially claimed that a stranger had taken the children.
South Carolina’s parole board can consider whether some prisoners may be released before completing their sentences. Smith’s case has brought her sons’ father, David Smith, and the board into focus, as well as questions about how a person’s conduct and time in prison are weighed when considering release.