World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
‘The Fantasticks’ review: World’s longest-running musical returns — with a twist
The world’s longest-running musical, “The Fantasticks”, has returned in a Broadway production that changes three roles’ genders. Director Christopher Gattelli’s staging recasts the two young lovers as men and their scheming fathers as mothers, updating some dated character dynamics while keeping the show’s light-hearted spirit.
The musical ran off Broadway for more than 50 years, closing in 2017, and this revival opened at the Hayes Theater. Its familiar plot follows Matt and Lewis, whose mothers invent a feud and build a wall to encourage the boys to fall in love. The review praises the score and the chemistry of Nathan Levy and Maxim Chlumecky, as well as performances by Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer and Ruthie Ann Miles.
In short
- The long-running musical returns with two male lovers.
- Its role changes refresh dated dynamics while preserving the original spirit.
- The review highlights the score and the cast’s performances.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The gender-swapped casting can make a familiar romance feel newly relevant, while loosening dated assumptions about courtship and parental roles. By retaining the show’s plot, score and playful spirit, the revival invites audiences to see how its themes work in a different family dynamic.
The case against
Changing the lovers and parents’ genders may alter the relationships that give the original its particular comic and romantic texture. Viewers who value the musical’s familiar character dynamics could feel the recasting draws attention away from the writing and music, or changes the show more than they would like.
Explained simply
The Fantasticks is a musical first staged in 1960, with a small cast and a story about two neighbours who pretend to feud. Their parents arrange for their children to fall in love, using the supposed rivalry as part of the plan. The show became known for its long off-Broadway run, which ended in 2017.
Its story draws on older ideas about young love and parental matchmaking. In different productions, directors can change how characters are presented while keeping the basic plot and songs. A change to the characters’ genders can shift how audiences read the family relationships and romance.