The Guardian view on Kemi Badenoch and the economy: a plan stuck in the Tory comfort zone | Editorial
The Guardian's editorial argues that Kemi Badenoch's appointment of Andrew Griffith as shadow chancellor undermines her stated strategy of making economic competence the centrepiece of her attack on the new Labour government under Andy Burnham. It contends that her choice reveals a lack of insight into why the Conservatives lost the last election, favouring a figure who can grab attention over one with sound economic judgment, and reflects a retreat into ideological comfort rather than genuine renewal.
The piece notes that Badenoch, having outlasted Sir Keir Starmer (whose downfall was largely self-inflicted), hopes fiscal discipline will be her strongest card against his successor. At prime minister's questions, she branded Burnham a "spendthrift" who will avoid tough decisions and rely on tax rises. However, her new shadow chancellor, Griffith, previously backed Liz Truss's disastrous 2022 mini-budget, replacing the less prominent Mel Stride, a choice the editorial says exposes the limits of Badenoch's "small-state" repositioning against both Labour and Reform UK.
In short
- Guardian editorial criticises Badenoch's new shadow chancellor pick, Andrew Griffith.
- Griffith backed Liz Truss's 2022 mini-budget; replaces Mel Stride.
- Badenoch targets Burnham as "spendthrift" but strategy called a retreat, not renewal.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Badenoch could argue that Griffith’s appointment gives the Conservatives a forceful advocate for lower taxes, spending restraint and a smaller state, making their economic alternative clearer to voters. His support for the Truss mini-budget may reflect a willingness to pursue that agenda boldly, while Badenoch can present fiscal discipline as a contrast with a Labour government she expects to raise taxes.
The case against
Critics could argue that choosing Griffith, given his support for the 2022 mini-budget, makes it harder for Badenoch to establish credibility on economic judgement and fiscal discipline. If her aim is to persuade voters that the Conservatives have learned from defeat, appointing a figure associated with a damaging economic episode may look like a return to familiar ideology rather than a convincing renewal.
Explained simply
Kemi Badenoch leads the Conservative Party, which is now in opposition to the Labour government led by Andy Burnham. The shadow chancellor speaks for the Conservatives on economic policy and scrutinises the government’s plans for taxes, spending and public services.
Economic policy has been a major point of debate in British politics, including over how much the government should spend and how it should pay for that spending. Liz Truss’s 2022 mini-budget, which proposed large tax cuts, was followed by sharp turmoil in financial markets and her resignation as prime minister.
The Conservatives’ recent election defeat has prompted debate within the party about how to regain voters’ trust on the economy. That debate matters because the opposition’s approach can shape public discussion of the government’s choices and the policies offered at the next election.
Art Business Celebrity Culture Economy Elections Entertainment Government Markets Politics