The Switch 2 Is About to Face Its Toughest Challenge Yet
Nintendo’s Switch 2 is facing an important test as FromSoftware arrives on the platform with Elden Ring: Tarnished Edition and the Switch 2-exclusive multiplayer game The Duskbloods. Their success could strengthen Nintendo’s long-running effort to secure major third-party support, particularly after the original Switch missed out on Elden Ring in 2022 because of hardware limitations.
Early reviews suggest Elden Ring works well as a handheld experience, though it performs less smoothly than on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X. The Duskbloods has drawn mixed reactions after its network test: some players welcome its unusual points-based elimination format, while others question whether it suits FromSoftware’s strengths. Nintendo and FromSoftware’s future partnership may depend on whether players accept these compromises and embrace the new exclusive.
- FromSoftware’s Switch 2 debut is a major third-party test.
- Elden Ring is well received, despite lower performance.
- The Duskbloods has prompted divided early reactions.
New here? Start with this
Nintendo makes the Switch 2, a console that can be used with a television or as a handheld device. Big games made by companies outside Nintendo can help attract buyers, but differences in hardware can affect how well demanding games run. The original Switch did not get Elden Ring when it launched in 2022.
FromSoftware is the Japanese studio behind Elden Ring and The Duskbloods. Elden Ring is a large fantasy adventure, while The Duskbloods is a multiplayer game made exclusively for Switch 2. How well they suit the console and its players could shape expectations for FromSoftware’s work on Nintendo systems.
Both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A successful release could show that Switch 2 can attract major third-party games and give players access to experiences previously unavailable on Nintendo hardware. Some performance compromises may be acceptable for the flexibility of handheld play, while The Duskbloods’ unusual format could help it stand out and broaden FromSoftware’s audience.
The case against
If Elden Ring performs noticeably less smoothly than on rival consoles, players may see the Switch 2 version as a poor substitute, weakening confidence in the platform’s ability to deliver demanding third-party games. Mixed reactions to The Duskbloods’ format also raise a fair question about whether the exclusive will appeal enough to sustain the partnership and justify future investment.