World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
This Company Turns American Milk Into Canadian Cheese. Tariffs Are Curdling Those Plans.
President Donald Trump’s tariffs on Canadian dairy imports have disrupted a supply chain in which American milk is processed into cheese in Ontario and then sold back in the United States. Gellert Global Group, a major importer and distributor, says the 50 per cent tariffs have made that business model unsustainable and is challenging them in court.
Company co-CEO Tom Gellert says about half of the cheese imported from Canada into the US is made with American milk, and estimates the tariffs have cost his business $40 million. Canada’s tariffs on US dairy apply after imports exceed quotas set under the USMCA; meanwhile, US dairy exports to Canada grew 67 per cent between 2021 and 2024. The lawsuit argues that the Trump administration’s use of a 1930 law to impose the tariffs is unlawful and that it failed to follow the law’s requirements.
In short
- US tariffs threaten a cross-border dairy supply chain.
- Gellert Global Group estimates a $40 million loss.
- The company is challenging the tariffs in court.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The tariffs can be defended as a way to protect American producers and press for fairer access to Canada’s dairy market, where US exports face quotas and additional tariffs above them. Supporters may argue that the disruption is a necessary cost of challenging trade rules they see as disadvantaging US farmers, and that the administration has authority to act under the law it invoked.
The case against
Critics can argue that taxing cheese made in Canada from American milk penalises US farmers and businesses while raising costs and disrupting an established supply chain. They may also contend that the tariffs exceed the administration’s legal authority or were imposed without following required procedures, making a court challenge an appropriate way to test them.
Americas Business Companies Politics World