Culture news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Valerie Solanas’s obscenely funny Scum Manifesto is an unignorable burst of female outrage | Emily Woof
Emily Woof argues that Valerie Solanas’s *Scum Manifesto* remains a forceful challenge to male supremacy and a reminder that anger about exploitation and violence need not always be expressed politely. Woof says Solanas’s deliberately outrageous, often comic writing can help readers consider how rage might be turned into political resistance.
Published in 1968, the manifesto imagined abolishing money and compulsory work and proposed a “Society for Cutting Up Men”. That year Solanas shot and gravely wounded Andy Warhol; she was later diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia, and Woof says this history can overshadow her writing. Woof’s theatre piece *Revolver* revisits Solanas’s life and work, including her play *Up Your Ass*, which Warhol said he had lost.
In short
- Woof says Solanas’s furious writing still challenges male supremacy.
- *Scum Manifesto* mixed political proposals with savage comedy.
- *Revolver* revisits Solanas’s life, work and anger.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Woof’s case is that Solanas’s deliberately outrageous humour makes anger at male supremacy, exploitation and violence difficult to ignore, and can help turn that anger into political resistance. Her manifesto’s extreme proposals can be read as provocation rather than a practical programme, while attention to her writing allows it to be considered on its own terms rather than eclipsed by her later violence and mental illness.
The case against
A reasonable counterview is that the manifesto’s call for a society devoted to cutting up men risks making hostility toward men seem like a political solution, weakening its case against violence and obscuring the difference between satire and advocacy. Its shock tactics may also distract from more constructive arguments for equality, while revisiting Solanas’s work should not minimise the gravity of her shooting Warhol.
Explained simply
Valerie Solanas was an American writer whose 1968 pamphlet, *SCUM Manifesto*, used satire and deliberately extreme language to attack male power and propose a radically different society. Its title refers to the “Society for Cutting Up Men”, a provocation in a text that also imagined abolishing money and compulsory work.
Later that year, Solanas shot and seriously wounded artist Andy Warhol. She was subsequently diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia, and accounts of her life are often shaped by the shooting as well as by her writing. Actor and writer Emily Woof’s theatre piece *Revolver* revisits Solanas’s work and the story of her play *Up Your Ass*, which Warhol said he had lost.