Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Week 11 AP Top 25 Poll doesn’t feature much movement, but a laughable backend featuring Arizona and Ole Miss
The Week 11 AP college football poll kept its top nine teams unchanged after all of them won, while Wake Forest rose to No. 10 and Texas Tech fell to No. 11. The article argues that the poll’s lower places are less convincing, questioning whether Ole Miss and Arizona deserve their rankings.
Ole Miss remained ranked at No. 25 despite a 24-17 defeat by Oklahoma, leaving it 6-4 and outscored 66-24 over its last two games; Oklahoma, which beat the Rebels, received the most votes among unranked teams. Wake Forest climbed into the top 10 after beating SMU 49-7, while Arizona moved from No. 22 to No. 19 despite a 40-39 loss to No. 2 Utah; the article notes that Arizona’s seven wins include only one opponent with a winning record.
In short
- The AP poll’s top nine stayed unchanged.
- Wake Forest rose to No. 10 after a 49-7 win.
- Arizona climbed despite losing, while 6-4 Ole Miss stayed ranked.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The poll can reasonably reward a season’s overall record and strength of schedule rather than treating one recent loss as decisive. Ole Miss is still 6-4, while Arizona’s narrow defeat came against No. 2 Utah; voters may also see value in recognising competitive performances and avoiding excessive week-to-week swings.
The case against
Rankings should reflect current performance and the quality of wins, so keeping a 6-4 Ole Miss team in the poll after consecutive losses and a 66-24 scoring deficit is hard to justify, especially when the team that beat it remains outside the top 25. Arizona’s rise after losing, alongside a record built largely against teams without winning records, also raises questions about whether the poll is rewarding reputation or a close score more than demonstrated results.
Explained simply
The AP Top 25 is a weekly ranking of the leading teams in US college football, voted on by sports journalists. Teams near the top usually have strong records, though voters also consider how they have played and whom they have faced.
Ole Miss, Arizona and Wake Forest are teams in the NCAA’s top division, where schools compete across conferences and schedules of differing difficulty. A team’s win total does not show the whole picture: victories against strong opponents can carry more weight, while losses and recent performances may affect how voters judge a team.
The rankings can shape public perceptions of a team’s season and influence selection discussions for major postseason competitions. Comparing teams is difficult because they do not all play the same opponents, so voters weigh incomplete and sometimes conflicting evidence.