Culture news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Bombs, heists and big cats: TV’s 25 best true-crime shows ever
This Guardian article rounds up what its writers consider the 25 best true-crime television shows ever made, spanning cold-case murders, elaborate scams, cults and heists. It comes as Netflix releases A Toxic Love Story, a new documentary about a California couple who framed an innocent woman, which critics are calling a return to form for the genre a decade after Making a Murderer kickstarted the true-crime boom.
The list includes acclaimed titles such as OJ: Made in America, the Oscar- and Emmy-winning ESPN account of OJ Simpson's rise and trial; The Jinx, HBO's investigation into real estate heir Robert Durst; Girl in the Picture, about an abduction and identity fraud case; The Alabama Solution, assembled from contraband prison footage exposing guard brutality; Evil Genius, covering a bizarre 2003 bank heist involving a bomb collar; and Capturing the Friedmans, a study of a father and son convicted of child abuse offences. Most of the featured shows are available on Netflix, with others found on Disney+, Sky/Now and HBO Max.
In short
- Guardian critics list the 25 best true-crime TV shows of all time
- Prompted by Netflix's new documentary A Toxic Love Story
- Highlights include OJ: Made in America, The Jinx and Evil Genius
Explained simply
True-crime television uses real cases as the basis for documentaries and series, often combining interviews, archive footage and investigations. The programmes in this list cover a wide range of events, from murders and fraud to prison abuse and robberies.
The people at the centre may include suspects, victims, relatives, witnesses, journalists and investigators. Some cases led to convictions or public trials; others raise questions about evidence, identity or how justice was pursued.
These programmes can bring complex cases to a large audience and influence how viewers understand them. Their accounts are shaped by what evidence is available and by the choices made in presenting it, so different programmes may leave different impressions of the same events.