Video games news, releases, esports and culture — all the biggest gaming stories in one place.
38 Years Later, Calvin and Hobbes’ Lost Character Remains Bill Watterson’s Biggest Failure
Bill Watterson introduced Calvin’s Uncle Max in a two-week 1988 arc, intending him to broaden the world of *Calvin and Hobbes*. Max never returned, making the storyline a rare abandoned thread in a comic that otherwise stayed close to its original vision throughout its ten-year run.
Max visits Calvin’s family after being absent since Calvin was a baby, and briefly becomes a new character for Calvin and his parents to interact with. In a 1995 retrospective, Watterson explained that writing scenes between Max and Calvin’s unnamed parents was difficult, and Max offered fewer story possibilities than expected, so he dropped the character.
In short
- Uncle Max appeared for two weeks in 1988.
- Watterson had planned to bring him back.
- He abandoned the idea because it limited story options.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Dropping Uncle Max was a sound creative choice: Watterson found that the character was difficult to write into scenes with Calvin’s parents and opened fewer story possibilities than expected. Since the strip otherwise remained close to its original vision, leaving Max behind may have helped preserve its focus and consistency.
The case against
Uncle Max offered a chance to expand Calvin’s family and introduce new relationships and storylines, so abandoning him left a potentially rich part of the comic unexplored. The arc’s rarity also makes the decision look like a missed opportunity, even if the character proved difficult to develop.
Explained simply
Calvin and Hobbes is a newspaper comic strip by American cartoonist Bill Watterson, centred on lively six-year-old Calvin and his stuffed tiger Hobbes. It ran from 1985 to 1995 and was known for its imaginative humour and Watterson’s close control over the characters and stories.
Calvin’s family includes his unnamed parents, who often respond to his schemes, and Uncle Max, a relative who appears in a short 1988 storyline. Watterson later said he found it difficult to write scenes involving Max and Calvin’s parents, and that the character opened up fewer story possibilities than he had expected.