Bitter Argentina players turn their backs to Spain’s World Cup trophy lift after violence marred winners’ celebrations – as lip-reader reveals what furious star said to winning captain Rodri during brawl

Steelman: both sides, in good faith

The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.

The case for

Argentina's response reflected the extraordinary emotional toll of losing a World Cup final in the final moments under what they viewed as controversial refereeing. The disallowed goal was a pivotal moment that many believed should have stood, and losing the tournament's most prestigious prize on such contentious terms would be devastating for any player. Their emotional reaction – raw, unfiltered, human – is understandable when recognising the stakes involved and the disputed nature of the decision that sealed their fate.

The case against

Sport fundamentally requires accepting defeat, and Spain won the match according to the rules that governed it. Whilst the disallowed goal may have been controversial, the referee's decision stands, and protesting through altercations and turning their backs during Spain's trophy ceremony crosses into disrespect and poor sportsmanship. World-class athletes are expected to maintain composure even in devastating circumstances; their behaviour set a poor example and violated the dignity that should characterise competition at this level.