New releases, music videos and album news — indie, rap, rock and pop. Always covering Ren, Chris Webby, Sam Tompkins, bbno$, CHINCHILLA, Muse, Yungblud and more.
In 1978, the Grateful Dead tried to sell out and found out it wasn’t quite so easy: “We failed miserably”
In 1978, the Grateful Dead tried to make a more commercially successful album with *Shakedown Street*, but the experiment failed to produce the radio hit they sought. Percussionist Mickey Hart later described the attempt as a failure, while the article argues the record’s commercial direction clashed with the band’s identity as an improvisational live act.
The album still included songs that became lasting parts of the band’s repertoire, including its title track and “Fire on the Mountain”. The article singles out “France” as the misstep: Bob Weir called it a “spectacular failure of judgment”, and songwriter Robert Hunter said it had changed substantially from the lively Latin jam that inspired it. The band never performed “France” live.
In short
- The Dead’s attempt at a radio hit with *Shakedown Street* fell short.
- “Shakedown Street” and “Fire on the Mountain” endured.
- “France” was the album’s song the band never played live.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Aiming for broader commercial success was a reasonable attempt to sustain the band’s reach and introduce its music to more listeners. A polished, radio-friendly album could complement their improvisational live identity, and the record still yielded songs that became enduring parts of their repertoire.
The case against
The band’s distinctive appeal rested on improvisation and a strong live connection, so pursuing radio-friendly conventions risked weakening what made them compelling. The attempt did not deliver the hoped-for hit, and the fate of “France” suggests that reshaping the material for commercial aims could produce work even the band later judged unsuccessful.