Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
The Weakest Storyline in the Red Rising Trilogy Is Even Worse 10 Years Later
The article argues that the romance between Darrow and Mustang is the weakest part of Pierce Brown’s Red Rising trilogy, and that the gap feels more obvious when rereading the books years later. It says their relationship matters to the story’s themes of growing up and embracing change, but is not developed convincingly enough on the page.
The first book lays the groundwork for their attraction, but Golden Son skips two years in which they grow closer and become intimate. The article says readers are told about this development rather than shown it, while Darrow’s grief for his wife Eo and his concealed identity further complicate the romance. It suggests another potential partner might have fitted the trilogy’s themes better.
In short
- The article finds Darrow and Mustang’s romance unconvincing.
- Their relationship deepens off-page during a two-year gap.
- Darrow’s grief and deception add to the strain.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The romance is a weak point because the trilogy skips over the period when Darrow and Mustang grow close, leaving readers to accept a major change in their relationship without seeing it develop. Darrow’s grief for Eo and his hidden identity add further emotional complications that the books do not fully explore, making the romance feel less convincing on rereading.
The case against
The relationship can be read as an intentionally understated part of a fast-moving story, with the time jump reflecting how much changes off the page during Darrow’s rise. Its importance may lie less in romantic detail than in bringing together two characters whose changing loyalties and ideals serve the trilogy’s themes of growth and transformation.
Explained simply
Pierce Brown’s Red Rising trilogy is a science-fiction story about Darrow, a young man from an oppressed group who disguises himself to enter the ruling class. His fight against that hierarchy brings him into contact with Mustang, a fellow student who becomes an important ally and love interest.
Their relationship sits alongside the trilogy’s themes of identity, loss and personal change. Darrow’s grief for his wife, Eo, and the fact that he is hiding who he is shape how readers may understand his bond with Mustang.