World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Using law to try to silence abuse victims is ‘ultimate form of gaslighting’, MPs told
Survivors told MPs that lawsuits brought by alleged perpetrators of sexual abuse can be used to intimidate victims and discourage them from speaking publicly. Verity Nevitt, who was sued after she and her sister named a man they had reported to police, said such cases can recast the accused as the victim and the survivors as aggressors.
Nevitt said the case was driven by legal costs rather than whether the claims were true, and that her solicitor warned the sisters they would need £100,000 to reach the next hearing. Lawyers and campaigners told the Commons justice committee that these lawsuits can also deter journalists from reporting abuse; they called for stronger protections and cost limits. The committee heard that UK anti-Slapp law currently covers disclosures about economic crime, unlike broader laws in some other western democracies.
In short
- Survivors say lawsuits can be used to silence abuse allegations.
- Nevitt was told the case could cost £100,000 to continue.
- Campaigners want stronger anti-Slapp protections.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters of stronger anti-Slapp protections argue that abuse survivors and journalists should be able to discuss credible allegations in the public interest without being priced into silence by lengthy, ruinously expensive litigation. They say cost limits and broader legal safeguards could reduce intimidation while leaving genuine defamation claims available.
The case against
Those cautious about expanding protections argue that people accused of abuse also have a legitimate interest in protecting their reputations and challenging false claims. They may worry that broad safeguards or cost limits could make it harder to pursue valid cases, weaken accountability for inaccurate reporting, or shift the costs of harmful allegations onto defendants.
Explained simply
Sexual abuse survivors may report what happened to the police or speak about it publicly, while the person they accuse may deny the allegations. In some cases, that person can bring a civil lawsuit against the survivors over what they have said.
The cost and stress of defending a lawsuit can affect whether survivors feel able to speak, even before a court decides whether their claims are true. Lawyers and campaigners say the threat of such cases may also make journalists more cautious about reporting abuse.
UK law allows courts to deal with lawsuits intended to silence public-interest reporting on economic crime, but the protections do not broadly cover abuse disclosures. MPs are examining whether stronger safeguards could protect people from legal pressure while preserving the right to bring genuine claims.