Technology news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Human imperfections are ‘exactly’ why AI should never be used, says Rockstar’s mo-cap director
Actor Jesse James Rose says a Rockstar motion-capture director argued against using AI because it could not reproduce the unexpected details of human faces. The account highlights a creative concern about AI-generated performances: imperfections and spontaneous movements can produce distinctive results that a computer may not anticipate.
Rose says they spent a day having their face scanned for the game, making many expressions to capture facial details and muscle movements. When Rose could not move a particular muscle, they feared the scan was spoiled, but the director reportedly saw the unusual expression as evidence of why human actors mattered, saying a computer could not have created that face. The article gives no details on how much AI, if any, was used in GTA 6.
In short
- Jesse James Rose recounts a Rockstar director’s objection to AI.
- An unexpected facial expression was seen as creatively valuable.
- Rockstar’s use of AI in GTA 6 remains undisclosed.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
AI-generated performances may be useful for some production tasks, but they can struggle to reproduce the unplanned expressions and subtle irregularities that make a human performance distinctive. Preserving actors’ creative contribution and control can therefore support both artistic quality and respect for their work.
The case against
AI tools could still help with limited, repetitive or technically demanding tasks, while human actors and directors guide the performance and retain creative control. Used selectively, they may expand what a production can do without requiring every element to be generated or replacing the spontaneity of performers.
Explained simply
Motion capture records an actor’s movements and expressions so they can be recreated by a computer-generated character in a game or film. Facial scanning can capture details such as how muscles move when someone makes different expressions.
Jesse James Rose is an actor who says they took part in a face-scanning session for a Rockstar game. Rockstar makes the Grand Theft Auto series, including GTA 6; the account describes a director’s view of the value of human performances.
The debate matters because game makers can use computer tools to create or alter performances, while actors bring expressions and movements that may be difficult to plan in advance. The account does not say how much, if any, AI was used in GTA 6.