Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Stephen Miller is right: The Left is not liberal
Stephen Miller, described in the article as President Donald Trump’s new chief of staff, accused left-wing people of being driven by envy and hostility towards beauty, family life and religion. The opinion article endorses his claim, arguing that the modern left has moved away from its historic role in Western civilisation.
The excerpt provides no evidence or examples to support that argument, and gives no further details about how the left has changed over the past decade. Its central point is the author’s judgement that modern political movements on the left have abandoned their traditional liberal character.
In short
- Miller says the left is driven by envy and hatred.
- The author agrees and says the modern left has changed.
- The excerpt offers no supporting examples.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
One case for the article’s claim is that some contemporary left-wing movements give greater weight to equality and collective goals than to classical liberal priorities such as individual liberty, open debate and limited state power. If those priorities are sidelined, critics can reasonably argue that parts of the left have moved away from liberalism, even while pursuing aims they see as just.
The case against
A case against the claim is that the left is broad and internally diverse, and many left-wing traditions remain rooted in liberal commitments to equal rights, pluralism and personal freedom. The excerpt offers no examples showing that these commitments have been abandoned, so it does not establish that the left as a whole is no longer liberal.
Explained simply
In this article, “the left” means political movements and people generally associated with support for social equality and reform. “Liberal” can mean different things, but in politics it often refers to protecting individual rights, open debate and limits on government power.
Stephen Miller is a US political figure associated with Donald Trump. The article presents his criticism of left-wing people as part of a wider argument about whether today’s left still fits the liberal tradition; the excerpt gives no examples or evidence to show how that tradition has changed.